Is Copyright Infringement Really a Crime?

The Indy Star reports that a man named Rich Bell has been suing people for unauthorized use of his photo of the Indianapolis skyline. Some people, according to Bell and the Indy Star even replaced Bell’s copyright notice with their own.

But not everyone is on Bell’s side.

Mitch Stoltz of the Electronic Frontier Foundation is quoted in the article as arguing that the legal penalties are disproportionate to the crime: “Those really high penalties create an incentive to embark on litigation campaigns.” And unnamed people are quoted in the article as calling Bell a “copyright troll.”

It seems to me that people shouldn’t steal, and I’m not convinced by arguments that the Internet has made it too easy to do so, or that everyone is doing it. It’s also apparently pretty easy and common to shoplift, but we seem to have much less tolerance for that.

Why?

The photo and more details are here: Copyright infringement lawsuits make Indy skyline photo worth a lot more than 1,000 words.

About J.M. Hoffman

A prolific writer and avid photographer, J.M. Hoffman picked up his first camera when he was eight years old. And even though he abhors a cliche, he never looked back. Acclaimed as a "master raconteur" who writes with a "flair" (Times Literary Supplement of London), Hoffman authored two non-fiction books and contributed to over a dozen others before writing The Warwick Files. He continues to write fiction and non-fiction. In addition to writing and traveling the world lecturing about his books, Hoffman has also directed a dance troupe, taught darkroom technique, and explored Patagonia on horseback. From time to time he can be seen playing table tennis poorly at the WTCC. He lives just north of New York City.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


X
Lux Umbraque is in beta. Most features are working. Some are not, and some basic content is still being uploaded.... (keep reading.)